From The New York
Times
Our Gas Guzzlers, Their Lives
By Nicholas D. Kristoff
June 28, 2007
BUJUMBURA, Burundi
If we need any more proof that life is unfair, it is that
subsistence villagers here in Africa will pay with their lives for our refusal
to curb greenhouse gas emissions.
When we think of climate change, we tend to focus on Alaskan
villages or New Orleans hurricanes. But the people who will suffer the worst
will be those living in countries like this, even though they don't contribute
at all to global warming.
My win-a-trip journey with a student and a teacher has taken us to
Burundi, which the World Bank's latest report shows to be the poorest country
in the world. People in Burundi have an annual average income of $100, nearly
one child in five dies before the age of five, and life expectancy is 45.
Against that grim backdrop, changing weather patterns in recent
years have already caused crop failures -- and when the crops fail here, people
starve. In short, our greenhouse gases are killing people here.
''If the harvest fails in the West, then you have stocks and can
get by,'' said Gerard Rusuku, an agriculture scientist here who has been
studying the impact of global warming in Africa. ''Here, we're much more
vulnerable. If climate change causes a crop failure here, there's famine.''
Guillaume Foliot of the World Food Program notes that farmers here
overwhelmingly agree that the weather has already become more erratic, leading
to lost crops. And any visitor can see that something is amiss: Africa's
''great lakes'' are shrinking.
Burundi is on Lake Tanganyika, which is still a vast expanse of
water. But the shoreline has retreated 50 feet in the last four years, and
ships can no longer reach the port.
''Even the hippos are unhappy,'' said Alexander Mbarubukeye, a
fisherman on the lake, referring to the hippos that occasionally waddled into
town before the lake retreated.
The biggest of Africa's great lakes, Lake Victoria, was dropping
by a vertical half-inch a day for much of last year. And far to the north, once
enormous Lake Chad has nearly vanished. The reasons for the dipping lake levels
seem to include climate change.
Greenhouse gases actually have the greatest impact at high
latitudes -- the Arctic and Antarctica. But the impact there isn't all bad
(Canada will gain a northwest passage), and the countries there are rich enough
to absorb the shocks.
In contrast, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change warned
this year that the consequences for Africa will be particularly harsh because
of the region's poverty and vulnerability. It foresees water shortages and crop
failures in much of Africa.
''Projected reductions in yield in some countries could be as much
as 50 percent by 2020, and crop net revenues could fall as much as 90
percent,'' the panel warned. It also cautioned that warming temperatures could
lead malaria to spread to highland areas. Another concern is that scarcities of
food and water will trigger wars. More than five million lives have already
been lost since 1994 in wars in Rwanda, Burundi and Congo, and one factor was
competition for scarce resources.
''It seems to me rather like pouring petrol onto a burning fire,''
Jock Stirrup, the chief of the British defense staff, told a meeting in London
this month. He noted that climate change could cause weak states to collapse.
Yoweri Museveni, Uganda's president, describes climate change as
''the latest form of aggression'' by rich countries against Africa. He has a
point. Charles Ehrhart, a Care staff member in Kenya who works full time on
climate-change issues, says that the negative impact of the West's carbon
emissions will overwhelm the positive effects of aid.
''It's at the least disastrous and quite possibly catastrophic,''
Mr. Ehrhart said of the climate effects on Africa. ''Life was difficult, but
with climate change it turns deadly.''
''That's what hits the alarm bells for an organization like
Care,'' he added. ''How can we ever achieve our mission in this situation?''
All this makes it utterly reckless
that we fail to institute a carbon tax or at least a cap-and-trade system for
emissions. The cost of our environmental irresponsibility will be measured in
thousands of children dying of hunger, malaria and war.